• Cabinet
  • Bureaux
  • Carrières
  • Nouvelles
  • Étudiants
  • Anciens
  • Paiements
  • EN
Background Image
Bennett Jones Logo
  • Équipe
  • Services
  • Ressources
  • Recherche
  • EN Menu
  • Recherche mobile
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Voir tout
Domaines de pratique
Droit des sociétés Litiges Affaires réglementaires Droit fiscal Voir tout
Secteurs
Projets d’investissement Énergie Fonds et finances Mines Voir tout
Enjeux Strategiques
Gestion des crises et des risques Stratégie et solutions ESG Affaires gouvernementales et politiques publiques
Consultez les mandats représentatifs
Expérience internationale
Perspectives Nouvelles Événements
Série sur la nouvelle économie de l’énergie Balado « Business Law Talks » Perspectives économiques
L'ESG et le DSI S’abonner
Équipe
Domaines de pratique
Secteurs
Enjeux Strategiques
Mandats représentatifs
Cabinet
Bureaux
Nouvelles
Carrières
Perspectives
Étudiants
Événements
Recherche
Anciens
Paiements
S’abonner

Restez au fait des dernières nouvelles et de nos événements dans le domaine des affaires et celui du droit.

LinkedIn LinkedIn Twitter Twitter Vimeo Vimeo
 

Assessing the Potential Risks to the Sustainability of the Government of Canada's Current Fiscal Plan

23 janvier 2023

The Government of Canada's current fiscal plan may not tell the full story of the country's financial path.

The purpose of this paper is to explore the way two fiscal anchors, the debt/GDP ratio and the interest cost revenue ratio, are likely to evolve over the decade ahead (2032-33) under five plausible economic scenarios and thus to assess the implications of these two anchors as a guide to sustainable fiscal policy actions.

In Budget 2022 and the November economic statement the federal government laid out a fiscal plan against a plausible but optimistic set of assumptions about the economic and interest rate context in which it would be operating through 2027. In our base scenario, we incorporate these assumptions and extend the fiscal plan through to 2032. In this base scenario, the net debt/GDP ratio continues to decline to pre-COVID level by 2032 and interest cost/revenue ratio stays below 10%. Thus, if the federal government were to limit spending and borrowing to levels set out in the Fall Economic Statement (FES) 2022, these two ratios indicate that the federal government would be able to continue to access capital markets without paying a higher risk premium, although at interest rates higher than in the pre-COVID period as global interest rates are permanently higher.

But there are three big risks to this base scenario even assuming that real potential growth of 1.8% per annum and inflation of 2% are achieved and the current tax structure remains in place:

  1. planned spending is unlikely to be adequate to deliver the policy goals set out by the government;
  2. there is a high likelihood of a more severe recession in 2023; and
  3. medium-run inflation pressures are highly likely to continue and interest rates to remain well above pre-COVID levels.

When each of these risks is modelled individually, the debt/GDP ratio does decline somewhat but remains at or above 40% every year to 2032 and the interest cost/revenue ratio rises somewhat above 10% by or before fiscal year (FY) 2027-28.

As these three risks are likely to occur simultaneously at least to some degree, in a fifth scenario the two ratios are calculated taking account of all three risks combined. In this case the debt/ GDP ratio would remain near 50% throughout the whole period and the interest cost/revenue ratio would steadily rise well above 10% especially beyond 2026-27. Were this to be the case, continued federal government access to capital markets on current favourable terms would be seriously threatened and the 10-year rate on Canada bonds could well be higher than 3.7% toward the end of the 2020’s. Moreover, as the knock-on effect of higher rates and fiscal deterioration could permanently impair the private (and public) investments needed to secure the 1.8% potential real growth assumed in our analysis, our conclusion is that there is a significant risk in the fiscal plan as laid out in Budget 2022 and the fall FES may not be sustainable in the decade ahead.

Prepared in collaboration with Robert Asselin, Senior Vice President of Policy at the Business Council of Canada.

Exceptional knowledge of Canadian government, international affairs, cross-border issues and policy development is a key component of our ability to provide clients with strategic legal and business advice in a business environment that is increasingly complex and international in scope. Members of our Public Policy group have been invaluable for their leadership in shaping public policy in Canada, and in developing business responses to those policies.

Connect with us to learn more about how we can help you navigate your business' needs.

Work with our Public Policy Group

Principales personnes-ressources

  • David A. Dodge O.C. David A. Dodge O.C., Conseiller principal
  • Richard  Dion Richard Dion, Conseiller principal, Affaires

Celebrating our Centennial Chronicle

Liens connexes

  • Perspectives
  • Nouvelles
  • S’abonner

Expertise connexe

  • Affaires gouvernementales et politiques publiques

Articles récents

Annonces

Jason Kenney Joins Bennett Jones as Senior Advisor

01 février 2023
       

Présentations

U.S. Export and Re-Export Compliance for Canadian Operations

01 février 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

Canadian Government Cannot Rely on More Borrowing to Fund Pledges

27 janvier 2023
       

Présentations

The Evolution of Economic Crime, Asset Recovery, Money Laundering and Enforcement

26 janvier 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

Why Ottawa's Plans to Restore Fiscal Balance Are On Shaky Ground

26 janvier 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

Canada Needs to Get Its Act Together on Growth

25 janvier 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

Canada's Spending Plans Will be Threatened by Higher Interest Rates and Looming Recession

25 janvier 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

David Dodge on Power Play: Canada's Fiscal Plan is Not the Full Story

25 janvier 2023
       

Dans les nouvelles

Federal Government is Underestimating Risks of Recession and Higher Interest Rates

25 janvier 2023
       
Bennett Jones Centennial Footer
Bennett Jones Centennial Footer
Cabinet
  • Leadership
  • Diversité
  • Communauté
  • Innovation
  • Sécurité
  • Historique
Bureaux
  • Calgary
  • Edmonton
  • Montréal
  • Ottawa
  • Toronto
  • Vancouver
  • New York
Se connecter
  • Perspectives
  • Nouvelles
  • Événements
  • Carrières
  • Étudiants
  • Anciens
S’abonner

Restez au fait des dernières nouvelles et de nos événements dans le domaine des affaires et celui du droit.

LinkedIn LinkedIn Twitter Twitter Vimeo Vimeo
© Bennett Jones LLP 2023. Tous droits réservés.
  • Politique de confidentialité
  • Avis de non-responsabilité
  • Conditions d’utilisation
Logo Bennett Jones