• About
  • Offices
  • Careers
  • News
  • Students
  • Alumni
  • Payments
  • FR
Background Image
Bennett Jones Logo
  • People
  • Expertise
  • Knowledge
  • Search
  • FR Menu
  • Search Mobile
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
View all
Practices
Corporate Litigation Regulatory Tax View all
Industries
Capital Projects Energy Funds & Finance Mining View all
Advisory
Crisis & Risk Management ESG Strategy and Solutions Governmental Affairs & Public Policy
View Client Work
International Experience
Insights News Events
New Energy Economy Series Business Law Talks Podcast Economic Outlook
ESG & the CIO Subscribe
People
Practices
Industries
Advisory Services
Client Work
About
Offices
News
Careers
Insights
Law Students
Events
Search
Alumni
Payments
Subscribe

Stay informed on the latest business and legal insights and events.

LinkedIn LinkedIn Twitter Twitter Vimeo Vimeo
 
Blog

Ontario Court of Appeal says Draft Expert Reports are not Producible

January 29, 2015

The Court of Appeal for Ontario confirmed today that:

  1. counsel can and should discuss draft expert reports with their expert witnesses, and
  2. draft reports and other communications between counsel and expert witnesses are presumptively privileged and need not be disclosed "absent a factual foundation to support a reasonable suspicion that counsel improperly influenced the expert".

The decision is Moore v Getahun, 2015 ONCA 55. In the court below, the trial judge had ruled, among other things, that counsel should not have any undocumented discussions with expert witnesses and, in particular, should not review and comment on draft reports.

The decision set off a mini-firestorm in the legal and expert witness community. The appeal involved no fewer than six intervening legal and expert witness associations, some of whom had struck committees to consider the issues raised by the lower court decision. Even the victorious plaintiff acknowledged that the trial judge had gone too far.

The Court of Appeal agreed and helpfully clarified the law on communications between counsel and experts and the disclosure of expert reports. Prior to this decision, some lower courts had required production of draft expert reports, the risk of which led counsel and experts to behave as though drafts could be produced in almost every case.

The Court of Appeal confirmed that production is the exception, not the rule. Draft reports and other communication between counsel and experts are presumptively litigation privileged and shielded from production unless the party requesting disclosure can demonstrate a factual foundation to support a reasonable suspicion that counsel improperly influenced the expert. This will be a heavy burden in most cases.

Following this decision, we can expect many fewer instances in which draft expert reports are disclosed. Hopefully, this will reduce the time and cost parties spend avoiding creating drafts or fighting about the meaning of slight changes between drafts so that everyone can focus on the merits of the opinions themselves.

Download PDF

Author

  • Emrys  Davis Emrys Davis, Partner

How Sustainable is the Government of Canada's Current Fiscal Plan?

Related Links

  • Insights
  • Media
  • Subscribe

Recent Posts

Blog

Application of Statutory Bar to Workplace Bullying and Harassment Claims

March 20, 2023
       

Blog

The Current State of Canada's ZEV Market

March 20, 2023
       

Blog

Ontario Initiates Consultation on Permanent Framework [...]

March 17, 2023
       

Blog

Court of Appeal Endorses Draconian Deterrent to Insurance Fraud

March 15, 2023
       

Blog

Saskatchewan Makes it Easier to Adopt Orphan Wells

March 15, 2023
       
Bennett Jones Centennial Footer
Bennett Jones Centennial Footer
About
  • Leadership
  • Diversity
  • Community
  • Innovation
  • Security
  • History
Offices
  • Calgary
  • Edmonton
  • Montréal
  • Ottawa
  • Toronto
  • Vancouver
  • New York
Connect
  • Insights
  • News
  • Events
  • Careers
  • Students
  • Alumni
Subscribe

Stay informed on the latest business and legal insights and events.

LinkedIn LinkedIn Twitter Twitter Vimeo Vimeo
© Bennett Jones LLP 2023. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use
Logo Bennett Jones