Article

Summary Applications on Duty to Defend

July 29, 2022
Social Media
Download
Download
Read Mode
Subscribe
Summarize

Christine A. Viney, Bruce Mellett and Patrick Schembri write about the Alberta Court of Appeal's summary of the key principles that apply when an insured seeks a declaration that an insurer’s duty to defend has been triggered before liability in the underlying action has been determined in the Lawyer's Daily.

They write, "The court repeatedly emphasizes the need to avoid premature findings of fact that could affect liability in the underlying action" and "finds the lower court’s interpretation of the policy reviewable on a deferential standard, on the basis that the policy under consideration was not a standard form contract."

"In reviewing the key principles applicable to summary proceedings in which an insured seeks confirmation that its insurer is obliged to defend a claim, the Alberta Court of Appeal emphasizes the limited role of factual findings, particularly when those findings may be relevant to liability in the underlying action."

In Optrics Inc. v Lloyd’s Underwriters 2022 ABCA 26, "this led the Court of Appeal to adopt a more expansive view of the potential meaning of the contract between the parties and to reject the lower court’s interpretation of that contract as premature."

Read the full article on the Lawyer's Daily website.

Social Media
Download
Download
Subscribe
Republishing Requests

For permission to republish this or any other publication, contact Amrita Kochhar at kochhara@bennettjones.com.

For informational purposes only

This publication provides an overview of legal trends and updates for informational purposes only. For personalized legal advice, please contact the authors.

From the Same Authors

See All
Raising the Low Bar Plaintiffs Seek New Strategies to Prove Common Issues for Certification
Blog

Raising the “Low Bar”: Plaintiffs Seek New Strategies to Prove Common Issues for Certification

May 22, 2025
Christine A. VineyEthan Z. SchiffSidney (Sid) Brejak
Christine A. Viney, Ethan Z. Schiff & Sidney (Sid) Brejak
Class Actions Looking Forward 2025
Update

Class Actions: Looking Forward 2025

May 22, 2025
Emrys DavisMichael A. Eizenga L.S.M.Gannon Beaulne
& 18 more
Supreme Court of Canada Rules Impact Assessment Act Unconstitutional
Blog

Supreme Court of Canada Rules Impact Assessment Act Unconstitutional

October 13, 2023
E. Bruce Mellett KCSean AssiéAdam J. Williams
E. Bruce Mellett KC, Sean Assié & Adam J. Williams

Latest Insights

See All Insights
The PE Briefing Q3 2025
Blog

The Q3 2025 PE Briefing

October 7, 2025
Dom SorbaraElizabeth K. DylkeJames G. Morand
& 1 more
Navigating the World of Online Canadian Sweepstakes
Blog

Navigating the World of Online Canadian Sweepstakes: Legal Pitfalls and the Role of AI

October 6, 2025
Benjamin K. ReingoldStephen D. Burns
Benjamin K. Reingold & Stephen D. Burns
Placeholder
Blog

New Legislative Proposals Boost the Appeal of Employee Ownership Trusts

October 3, 2025
Wesley R. NovotnyWade RitchieZachary Thacker
Wesley R. Novotny, Wade Ritchie & Zachary Thacker
The PE Briefing Q3 2025
Blog

The PE Briefing: Q3 2025

October 2, 2025
Dom SorbaraElizabeth K. DylkeJames G. Morand
& 1 more